Create Account
Sign In Create Account

6 Struggles in Retail Recruitment and How to Solve Them

March 2nd, 2021

Blog, Retail, Staffing, Background Checks, Hiring Process

5 min read

It’s been a rough year for retail. COVID-19 has presented a huge challenge for brick and mortar-based businesses, with many stores closing, reducing hours and staffing, and shifting to deliveries and remote, online-focused operations. For some people, the only shopping they could afford due to layoffs was in the grocery store. 

In Q2 of 2020, there was a 13.6% drop in retail sales in Canada according to StatCan - although this did manage to pick up in Q3. Retail recruitment strategies are a little different in 2021 compared to 2019.

Despite these unforeseen circumstances, retail recruitment is never-ending and presents with its own unique set of struggles. Today we will take a look at six of the most common and frustrating issues that we see in recruitment in the retail sector - and how to fix them. 

1. Balance of staffing types


Any retailer can experience issues with the number of full-time, part-time, and casual team members that they have on the books at any one time. These issues include:

  • Understaffing on some shifts
  • A need to have location-floating or department floating team members
  • Managers required on the floor when understaffed
  • Casuals seeking other employment if they aren’t rostered on often enough
  • Last-minute staff call-ins

The solution

A remote-login employee app for staffing swaps, last-minute availabilities, location/department swaps, etc. can help with these issues in day-to-day operations, but how about coming in at the very beginning in recruitment strategy to find the right balance of types of roles?

Predictive analysis can also help to solve this dilemma. By assessing daily staffing mixes over time via historical data, you can find the optimal mix of staff types to help avoid last-minute scrambles. By performing this analysis you can also identify underperforming locations, departments, and team members overall, and create strategies for improvement.

2. Poor location-based hiring strategies

“When it comes to sales and marketing, knowing your audience is crucial to be effective.” - Know Your Customers: How to Build Buyer Personas for Your Retail Store, Shopify

Why are some locations under-performing and some are smashing sales targets every month, even if they both have the same amount of foot traffic? Location-based demographics for your customer base can have a lot to do with poor sales numbers - even if it’s not because of their regular overall spending habits.

In retail, customers want to identify with the team members they come into contact with in-store. In an interaction with a team member who they’d never encounter out there in the real world they may be thrown off guard.

The solution

Hiring employees for each location should be dependent on your location demographics as well as customer personas. For instance, if you are a hardware store, you may have tradespeople come in who are just working a job in the area and will only be a customer once or for a limited time, or you might have homeowners in the area who will be repeat customers for decades. For staffing, your customer types should fit with staff types. Consider candidate personality types, backgrounds, and job location history. Some staff may fit better at different locations or may be better off in a non-customer facing role if they are only interested in one location. Our Employment Verification solution can help with checking potential hires’ employment history. 

3. Determining whether inexperienced applicants are worth it

Retail Blog

Taking a chance on inexperienced candidates always feels like a bit of a gamble. While you can see their education, volunteer work, personal interests, and perhaps other industry/roles on their CV, sometimes certain people just aren’t the right fit for retail - or even a regular, scheduled job. Hiring an inexperienced candidate who you end up having to let go can be a costly and irritating experience which puts you back at square one.

The solution

Don’t automatically discount candidates who have no retail or ‘real’ work experience. Conducting thorough paid training and a probationary period will allow you to make the right decision long term. This is also why retailers often have plenty of casual roles going. Hiring otherwise good-fit candidates without work experience in casual roles offers the opportunity to see if they have potential as full-time employees or even managers. Make sure to use fast background checking including police checks, education checks, and volunteer checks to ensure resume validity. This will also tick off boxes with compliance regulations.

4. Seasonal hiring

Indeed data for holiday retail recruitment from 2018 indicates a rise of job postings of 450% between August and November.

Tis the season… to be selling! Christmas is a huge time for workforce influx, and you’re competing with everyone else in the area for the same hires. There are also other seasonal fluctuations depending on your retail vertical - for instance, the lead-up to winter in women’s wear can see an uptick in foot traffic and sales. So, how can you ensure you are staffed accordingly for these changes in customer behaviours?

The solution

First up is knowing your seasonal fluctuations and starting the recruitment process early enough in advance. This can be determined by going over your historical data and predicting timing. To compete with other retailers you can look at starting recruitment cycles before them , offering better pay, perks, or conditions, reaching out to previous hires, as well as asking your own workforce and previous hires for recommendations - and rewarding them for any position filled thanks to their recommendation.

5. Staff retention


While the Covid situation means that the job market is competitive, and businesses aren’t struggling to retain talent, once ‘normality’ returns, if you haven’t treated your staff well they will look to greener pastures.

Do you have a high rate of staff turnover? Know the percentage who are long-termers? Staff retention can be difficult in retail, as it is often a stepping stone to another career. Your team is often made up of students, part-timers, those not quite ready to retire, or people needing an income while they are looking for a professional job.

The solution

Retaining staff has a lot to do with the culture you build with your company, location, and team. Many people stay on in a job long past their intentions if they love their company culture, management, and coworkers. Investing in culture is an investment in staff retention.

Besides culture, the other major way to encourage long-term employment is by investing in your staff’s career in retail. If they see their own potential to succeed and are encouraged to reach a high position in your company then they’re more likely to stay on.

Other ways to incentivize long term employment within your company include having lots of benefits such as: 

  • Free, interesting training for retail-based careers
  • Management pathways
  • Mentorship
  • Location/department swaps
  • Personal/team benefits (gift cards, products) for high performers
  • Yearly bonuses
  • Workshops
  • Fun family days, barbecues, or other social mixers

Make sure to include all these perks in your job descriptions. When candidates mention they enjoy the social and work culture aspects of a job during the interview, or aspire to be in management, then you can surmise they may be a long-termer.

6. Management hires that don’t work out


Every business knows that the best management hires are usually from within the company - they know the business, culture, products/services, and inner workings. That’s why nurturing staff from the floor through to management is a popular HR strategy. But what about when your retail business needs a refresh in management or you don’t have enough potential managers for an internal hire? Hiring the wrong external candidate can be a very expensive exercise if it doesn’t work out.

The solution

If you are unable to recruit from within the company, there are plenty of ways to look for excellent candidates externally. One of the easiest ways is using a professional networking platform like LinkedIn to find excellent candidates that meet your criteria.

Another way to try and guarantee that a hire works out is by hiring a different industry/vertical candidate who has worked with a company with similar values and culture. If you’re looking for big changes with upper management, look for candidates with relevant positions, work history, and company turnarounds within companies that you’d like to similarly emulate.

Many of the struggles in retail hiring can be overcome with new technology solutions which include our set of HR solutions to validate and verify candidates instantly. With enterprise partners like Loblaws, we’re trusted in the industry to make a big difference. Check out how it all works in action by scheduling a free demo with us.

Book Demo

 

About Certn

Certn is the leader in human risk intelligence solutions, focusing on providing real-time comprehensive background checks and ongoing risk monitoring for employees, contractors and tenants around the world. Used by leading employers, staffing firms, property management companies and the gig economy, Certn returns domestic and international criminal background checks, credit reports, reference checks, education verification, employment verification, motor vehicle records, identity verification and more in minutes. Through innovative, friendly, and compliant technology, Certn is advancing trusted connections around the world. 

Related articles

Owners: Protect Your Assets with Background Checks

You already have a lot to worry about when it comes to building your small business—we get it. So don’t add more work to your future by skipping a vital step. Background checks
5 min read

Streamline Hiring Process for a Better Candidate Experience

Streamline Hiring with Certn and Freshteam  On top of helping you learn meaningful information about your candidate, background checks can contribute to a better candidate
4 min read

Certn Named Leader in Background Checks

G2 Rates Certn Leader in Background Check Category TL;DR The G2 2023 market reports awarded Certn its usual badges for Leader and Easiest to Use, which is always something to
3 min read

How Background Checks Help Remote Teams

Behind every new hire is a team of people. If you work in HR you know hiring any new employee is an investment, from recruiting and hiring to training and onboarding. According to
3 min read

HR Trends Explained: Background Check APIs

According to Harvard researchers, the average employee toggles between different apps and windows more than 3,600 times a day. Which is...a lot. For HR professionals, minimizing
4 min read

What Is SOC 2

Developed by the Association of International Certified Professional Accountants (AICPA), Service Organization Control (SOC) 2 is an auditing procedure that verifies companies
3 min read

The Dangers of Not Doing Background Checks

Are background checks necessary? Is it okay to skip them? What happens when you do? These are questions that are worth asking if you run a business in the US, because the answers
6 min read

Canada Property Managers: How Background Checks Help

When Vancouver-based property management company Advent Real Estate Services started using Certn’s background screening, it found that the services helped solve all kinds of
4 min read

2022 HR Trends Background Screening Helps With

2023 is just around the corner. And while the workplace is very different from what it was at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020, to say the change is done is
6 min read

Beyond Risk: At Certn, It's All About Tech, Trust and Truth

The background check industry has too long revolved around risk and safety – intimidating topics. Many of our competitors use fear and uncertainty as a selling point. But at
3 min read

How The Hiring Processes have Changed and How We Can Adapt

Hiring isn’t a one–way process anymore. The industry is changing rapidly due to the global pandemic still affecting nearly 212,800 jobs just in January 2021 alone and with the
3 min read

The Global Solution to Remote Hiring - OneID™

  In recent months we, as a society, have learned the values of being able to do almost everything from the comfort of our own homes. Whether it be having groceries delivered or
2 min read

Win at hiring with the new Certn and Greenhouse integration

Hiring just got easier. Certn is glad to announce that we’re entering a partnership with another leader in the HR space, Greenhouse.  We provide the most comprehensive, AI-driven
2 min read

Certn: Growth Leaders Of Tomorrow

VICTORIA, B.C. April 14, 2020 Certn has been selected as one of Canada’s top tech companies in the information and communications industry. It was announced that Certn was added
1 min read

How Gig Work is Changing in COVID-19

The world of work has been an ever-changing landscape. But we’ve never seen shifts of this magnitude before. Everyone’s talking about Gig companies. Some experts say it’s due to
4 min read

Certn Partnership with Njoyn

At Certn provide a complete background check system for all your hiring needs with results available at lightning speed. We offer criminal record checks, credential verification,
3 min read

Land (and Retain) Talent With These Incentives For Retail

How can you land the best hires in retail recruitment?  It all starts with creating the ultimate job descriptions and an enticing workplace. But these job descriptions can’t just
2 min read

Solve These 6 Retail Recruitment Struggles

If you’re reading this, take a deep breath - you’ve made it through 2020; arguably one of the most paradigm shifting years of recent human history. The pandemic put our global
4 min read

Why You Need Background Checks for Retail

Is this your hiring process? You receive applicant resumes and review them, schedule and conduct interviews to determine which ones fit your needs, and then finally, present the
3 min read

DHR International - Client Spotlight Video

 

5 Tips for Hiring in a Recession

As the first point of contact for applicants, there’s often a lot of pressure on HR to make informed decisions and bring on the right people. This can be challenging when hiring
4 min read

Certn Background Check Process, Your Questions Answered

Background checks are an important pre-employment screening step. They help companies make more informed decisions when choosing which candidate to hire. What is Certn Background
3 min read

International Background Checks by Certn

So you're running a global business. This means you have international hiring laws and background screening policies to comply with. Maybe you’re not fully global yet, but the
2 min read

What Do Background Checks Reveal

Background checks are a standard practice nowadays with 94% of businesses reporting that they conduct some type of background check on their job candidates. But why do they do it?
3 min read

2023's Top 3 Trends in Background Screening

If you’re in recruitment or talent acquisition and you’re not adopting top employment screening trends like using a vendor who automates background checks or international
4 min read

Owners: Protect Your Assets with Background Checks

You already have a lot to worry about when it comes to building your small business—we get it. So don’t add more work to your future by skipping a vital step. Background checks
5 min read

Streamline Hiring Process for a Better Candidate Experience

Streamline Hiring with Certn and Freshteam  On top of helping you learn meaningful information about your candidate, background checks can contribute to a better candidate
4 min read

Certn Named Leader in Background Checks

G2 Rates Certn Leader in Background Check Category TL;DR The G2 2023 market reports awarded Certn its usual badges for Leader and Easiest to Use, which is always something to
3 min read

How Background Checks Help Remote Teams

Behind every new hire is a team of people. If you work in HR you know hiring any new employee is an investment, from recruiting and hiring to training and onboarding. According to
3 min read

HR Trends Explained: Background Check APIs

According to Harvard researchers, the average employee toggles between different apps and windows more than 3,600 times a day. Which is...a lot. For HR professionals, minimizing
4 min read

How to Overcome International Recruitment Challenges with Certn and Deel

As an HR specialist, what process gives you the biggest headache? The coordination? The communication? The compliance requirements? Now imagine these challenges on a global scale;
6 min read

The Dangers of Not Doing Background Checks

Are background checks necessary? Is it okay to skip them? What happens when you do? These are questions that are worth asking if you run a business in the US, because the answers
6 min read

Here's How Background Checks Help Improve Hiring

It’s no secret that background checks help your hiring team. They provide a last layer of security to protect your organization from negligent hiring and other problems. But a
3 min read

How Background Checks Benefit All Business Departments

Background checks are the kind of thing that often stay in the background. They might not be the first thing that comes to mind when your company is looking for ways to reduce
4 min read

Certn's Background Checks Are Easiest to Use

Certonians, the talented and hard-working people here at Certn put a lot of care into making our clients happy with their background checks. At Certn, we help our clients conduct
2 min read

7 FCRA Best Practices for US Employers

What is the FCRA?  Enacted back in 1970, the Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) was designed to promote fairness and accuracy and ensure data confidentiality for consumers
5 min read

Attract the Right Employees in 2022 With Certn and BreezyHR

Hiring the right employee for your company can be a daunting task. It’s essential to find someone who is the right addition to your company culture and has the skills you need to
3 min read

Enhance Your Security Controls with Certn and Tugboat Logic Integration

All business functions, including talent management and human resources - in an organization will need to undergo a security audit. Whenever that happens, your team needs to be
2 min read

How Background Checks Help Achieve SOC 2 Compliance

Think SOC 2 is a boring compliance topic? Think again. If you’re a SaaS startup, this designation gives you a competitive edge. Background checks are a key enabler of SOC
4 min read

Canada's Top Growing Companies: Certn's Outstanding Growth

Canada's Top Growing Companies Certn ranks 22 on The Globe and Mail’s third-annual ranking of Canada’s Top Growing Companies and we couldn't be more excited!  We're pleased to
2 min read

Beyond Risk: At Certn, It's All About Tech, Trust and Truth

The background check industry has too long revolved around risk and safety – intimidating topics. Many of our competitors use fear and uncertainty as a selling point. But at
3 min read

7 Reasons to Switch Background Check Providers

The hiring process has evolved over the years as companies move from hiring locally to screening candidates virtually across the world. Small- and medium-sized businesses today
4 min read

Top 3 Myths about Background Checks

  Chances are you have already formed an opinion about background checks even if you’ve never needed one. Background checks may seem daunting, but the process doesn’t have to be
3 min read

Why Background Checks Are an Asset to Your Hiring Team

Hiring mistakes cost money. Just how much, exactly? According to some estimates, a bad hire typically costs about 30% of their first-year salary. So it makes sense to try and
3 min read

3 Ways Background Checks Help Gig Work

Thanks to unprecedented times brought on by a global pandemic, the way that people work has changed drastically over the past year. Many organizations had no choice but to adapt
3 min read

Worried? Don't Be Intimidated By Background Checks

If you’re not familiar with or have any knowledge of the many benefits that background checks provide to businesses, then it is completely understandable why you may feel
3 min read

Background Checks Help Your Business Save Money

Background checks are a necessity in the modern business world as they keep your business safe from liability. Businesses that use background checks have proven that they are able
3 min read

Why Background Checks are the Answer to Safe Online Dating

Being able to provide human beings with resources to help them feel comfortable and safe is priceless to any organization. Recently one of the biggest online dating platforms with
3 min read

How The Hiring Processes have Changed and How We Can Adapt

Hiring isn’t a one–way process anymore. The industry is changing rapidly due to the global pandemic still affecting nearly 212,800 jobs just in January 2021 alone and with the
3 min read

Certn Lime: The Background Check Solution for SMBs

Certn Lime is a background check solution designed specifically for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) that issue a lower volume of checks annually. Our services have always
2 min read

The Certn Background Check Process

If it has been a while since you’ve done one, you might still think of background checks as inconvenient. But Certn’s Canadian clients know the long waits, trips to your local
7 min read

Canada's Cannabis Industry and Criminal Record Checks

Employment in the cannabis industry in Canada is growing. In 2018, Canada introduced legalized recreational cannabis to the nation through the Cannabis Act, and employment in the
4 min read

Police Check Turnaround Times are at All-Time Highs

Tis the season where if you’re planning to coach hockey, you should be thinking about getting your annual background check! However, many leagues run on volunteers and one thing
1 min read

Non-Profit Employee Background Screening Services

Don't let a bad hire ruin your reputation or compromise your mission. If you're a volunteer association or non-profit organization, you can trust Certn with your background checks
2 min read

Why You Need Background Checks for Retail

Is this your hiring process? You receive applicant resumes and review them, schedule and conduct interviews to determine which ones fit your needs, and then finally, present the
3 min read

5 Tips for Hiring in a Recession

As the first point of contact for applicants, there’s often a lot of pressure on HR to make informed decisions and bring on the right people. This can be challenging when hiring
4 min read

Streamline Hiring Process for a Better Candidate Experience

Streamline Hiring with Certn and Freshteam  On top of helping you learn meaningful information about your candidate, background checks can contribute to a better candidate
4 min read

How Background Checks Help Remote Teams

Behind every new hire is a team of people. If you work in HR you know hiring any new employee is an investment, from recruiting and hiring to training and onboarding. According to
3 min read

HR Trends Explained: Background Check APIs

According to Harvard researchers, the average employee toggles between different apps and windows more than 3,600 times a day. Which is...a lot. For HR professionals, minimizing
4 min read

How to Overcome International Recruitment Challenges with Certn and Deel

As an HR specialist, what process gives you the biggest headache? The coordination? The communication? The compliance requirements? Now imagine these challenges on a global scale;
6 min read

Reduce Your Time to Hire and Increase Hiring Efficiency

The hiring process is always evolving. Recruiters do one thing, and applicants adapt. Recruiters do another, and applicants adapt again. Build an algorithm that will filter CVs
7 min read

Toxic Workplace? 4 Tips to Discourage E-Presenteeism

The worker who’s always the first one to clock in and the last one to clock out, who answers emails and Slack messages at all hours of the day, and who always logs on (even when
6 min read

2022 HR Trends Background Screening Helps With

2023 is just around the corner. And while the workplace is very different from what it was at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020, to say the change is done is
6 min read

The Ultimate Guide to Hiring Remote Employees

Remote Hiring with Certn & SmartRecruiters The global job market has changed and workplaces have been required to get out of their comfort zones and offer more flexible working
5 min read

Here's How Background Checks Help Improve Hiring

It’s no secret that background checks help your hiring team. They provide a last layer of security to protect your organization from negligent hiring and other problems. But a
3 min read

Easiest Background Check Provider, According to G2

When a new G2 report comes out, it’s always pretty exciting. G2 is one of the most popular and trusted software review sites around. And part of what makes its reports so useful
3 min read

5 Biases in Hiring and How Technology Is Fighting Them

Bias in the hiring process—and the negative ramifications it leads to—can be an intimidating problem to tackle. It can be uncomfortable for hiring managers to identify their own
7 min read

Attract the Right Employees in 2022 With Certn and BreezyHR

Hiring the right employee for your company can be a daunting task. It’s essential to find someone who is the right addition to your company culture and has the skills you need to
3 min read

How SMS Text Messages Can Benefit Your Hiring Process

At Certn, we are always looking for innovative ways to help our customers be more efficient in the way that they manage their background screening strategy. The hiring process has
3 min read

Why Background Checks Are an Asset to Your Hiring Team

Hiring mistakes cost money. Just how much, exactly? According to some estimates, a bad hire typically costs about 30% of their first-year salary. So it makes sense to try and
3 min read

Worried? Don't Be Intimidated By Background Checks

If you’re not familiar with or have any knowledge of the many benefits that background checks provide to businesses, then it is completely understandable why you may feel
3 min read

Solve These 6 Retail Recruitment Struggles

If you’re reading this, take a deep breath - you’ve made it through 2020; arguably one of the most paradigm shifting years of recent human history. The pandemic put our global
4 min read

Why You Need Background Checks for Retail

Is this your hiring process? You receive applicant resumes and review them, schedule and conduct interviews to determine which ones fit your needs, and then finally, present the
3 min read